ARROW ENHANCE Waterproof Eyeliner + Brightener Customer Reviews

I got my birch box today and it has this product but not the black pencil - it's fine to have a smaller product however we can't accurately rate the product if we're only getting the highlighter end of the pencil! The defining end is a bit chalky for my liking. Average product that I won't use.

I love the sound of this product, but I’ve not actually received it in my box!

This eyeliner was amazing until I tried to sharpen it. Every time I attempted it snapped or broke which left it on usable.

I didn’t receive this in my box but liked the idea so purchased the full size. Pros: both liners go on wonderfully smoothly and genuinely last all day. Wonderful! Cons: first time I sharpened it, it snapped in half. Now the black half is clearly the shorter of the two and not that easy to use. It won’t last that long due to its size - it’ll simply be too small to handle properly. Really torn - I love it but also was annoyed at how easy it broke.

My first pencil was broken in half when I received it. Birchbox sent me a replacement which was also broken in half when it arrived. Super disappointed with this item.

Does not work very well, so was slightly disappointed with this product. The pink tip gets dirty quite easily as it picks up the colour of eyeshadow unfortunately.

Not sure about this, don’t even know how to use it?!

i only use black eyeliner and almost all the eyeliners i use smudge after an hour but this really does stay put! i just wish it came in black only or i would totally repurchase

As I can see in the photo this is dual sided. You, Birchbox sent me only the white one. The product was still used so I’m satisfied but you should send what is shown.

The liner had great staying power. It's really nice to apply and doesn't sting my eyes like some other liners. Would definitely purchase again.