I got my birch box today and it has this product but not the black pencil - it's fine to have a smaller product however we can't accurately rate the product if we're only getting the highlighter end of the pencil! The defining end is a bit chalky for my liking. Average product that I won't use.
Everyday eyes, this is perfect for everyday use with other make up to highlight my eyes.
I like this
Goes on well and doesn't nip my eyes. Seems to stay out and helps me look awake.
I use eyeliner everyday, it’s nice being able to try out different brands
The white is brilliant, really made my eyes stand out. I don't generally use a eyeliner pencil, normally use a pen but I can recommend just for the white liner pencil.