I got my birch box today and it has this product but not the black pencil - it's fine to have a smaller product however we can't accurately rate the product if we're only getting the highlighter end of the pencil! The defining end is a bit chalky for my liking. Average product that I won't use.
Found this liner to be very chalky and clumpy. The texture doesn’t seem right.
Good eye brightener
The pink side of the pencil is really good to brighten the inner corner of your eye after applying eyeshadow, however it lost a star because it doesn’t last that long.
Used this every day. I never tested the waterproof side of things but as an everyday quick liner it's a good choice.
Nice but not great
I love a brightener and usually use the benefit one. This one is a bit clumpy and hard to get off if it gets blotchy.